An AI ethics review board is evaluating a predictive policing system. Which ethical framework would MOST strongly counsel against deployment of this system in high-risk communities?
Select an answer to reveal the explanation.
Short Explanation and Infographic
Here's the deal — b is correct because a justice-based ethical framework (drawing on Rawlsian or critical theory approaches) would strongly counsel against predictive policing in high-risk communities due to the risk of feedback loops amplifying existing over-policing, disparate impact on minority communities, and compounded historical injustices. A might justify deployment if aggregate crime statistics improve.
Full explanation below image
Full Explanation
B is correct because a justice-based ethical framework (drawing on Rawlsian or critical theory approaches) would strongly counsel against predictive policing in high-risk communities due to the risk of feedback loops amplifying existing over-policing, disparate impact on minority communities, and compounded historical injustices. A might justify deployment if aggregate crime statistics improve. C and D do not directly address the systemic discrimination concern.